Skip to content

Gemini 4 Carbon · Writing

Gemini 4 Carbon for writing: our test runs

Gemini 4 Carbon ran our 5 writing prompts in llmwise, through the same pipeline your messages take. Here's every reply as it came, whether it passed, what it cost and what it counts as on Pro, next to the other models.

Based on 5 of our test runs on , through OpenRouter with the app's own prompt and settings.

Short answer

In our test runs on November 17, 2026, Gemini 4 Carbon passed 5 of 5 of our writing prompts (both hard ones): tied 1st of 27 models. Each reply counted as 1 message on Pro, where it has 62 a month, and cost $0.0063 to run on average.

Prompt by prompt

Each of the 5 writing prompts, and how Gemini 4 Carbon's reply did.

Gemini 4 Carbon on each writing prompt
PromptResultCostTime
Announce a second bakery shop on LinkedInEverydayPassed: Graded 4.5 of 5 on average (lowest 4).$0.010421.6 s
Rewrite corporate jargon in plain wordsEverydayPassed: Graded 4.3 of 5 on average (lowest 4).$0.008524.1 s
Decline a meeting and offer two timesEverydayPassed: Graded 5.0 of 5 on average (lowest 5).$0.00139.2 s
A product announcement with five rulesHardPassed: Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).$0.003311.0 s
Argue both sides of free busesHardPassed: Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).$0.008021.0 s

Every writing reply from Gemini 4 Carbon

  1. Announce a second bakery shop on LinkedIn

    An everyday prompt: “Announce a second bakery shop on LinkedIn”, in full.

    Passed: Graded 4.5 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    We have some happy news to share. On 14 November, Crumb & Co. is opening the doors to our second shop, right here in Leeds.
    
    When we started our small bakery, we simply wanted to make good bread, honest pastries, and a welcoming place for our neighbours. Thanks to our loyal customers and the hard work of our team, we are ready to bring those warm loaves to a new community.
    
    We have spent the last few months getting the shop ready, testing the ovens, and training a wonderful local crew.
    
    To celebrate opening day on 14 November, coffee is free for everyone who stops by. Come in, say hello, and enjoy a cup on us. We cannot wait to meet our new Leeds neighbours.

    637 tokens in, 1,955 out (1,798 of them reasoning) · 21.6 s · $0.0104 · 1 message on Pro · answered by google/gemini-4-carbon via Google AI Studio ·

  2. Rewrite corporate jargon in plain words

    An everyday prompt: “Rewrite corporate jargon in plain words”, in full.

    Passed: Graded 4.3 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    By having different departments work together, our third-quarter project put a new, customer-focused approach into action. Among our large business clients, this boosted key customer-retention metrics by 12% and slowed the pace of cancellations by 0.3 percentage points (30 basis points). At the same time, we scaled all of our customer communication channels to the right size to make the best use of our team’s time and capacity.

    668 tokens in, 1,570 out (1,475 of them reasoning) · 24.1 s · $0.0085 · 1 message on Pro · answered by google/gemini-4-carbon via Google AI Studio ·

  3. Decline a meeting and offer two times

    An everyday prompt: “Decline a meeting and offer two times”, in full.

    Passed: Graded 5.0 of 5 on average (lowest 5).

    Subject: Rescheduling Wednesday's Vendor Demo
    
    Hi Tom,
    
    Thank you for the invitation to the vendor demo. Unfortunately, I won't be able to make it this Wednesday at 11:00, as I am presenting to the board at that time. 
    
    I would still love to attend if we can reschedule. Would Thursday at 10:00 or Friday at 14:00 work for you and the vendor? 
    
    Let me know if either of those times suits, or feel free to go ahead without me and share the recording afterward if rescheduling isn't possible.
    
    Best regards,
    
    [Your Name]

    647 tokens in, 140 out · 9.2 s · $0.0013 · 1 message on Pro · answered by google/gemini-4-carbon via Google AI Studio ·

  4. A product announcement with five rules

    A hard prompt: “A product announcement with five rules”, in full.

    Passed: Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    Meet the Nordvik 2 desk lamp, designed for focused workspaces and quiet evenings. Its precision-engineered arm turns 270 degrees, directing glare-free light exactly where you need it. Adjust your brightness effortlessly, as the lamp dims in five steps from crisp task lighting to a soft ambient glow. Built for modern convenience, the Nordvik 2 charges from USB-C, keeping your desk free of proprietary cables and clutter. Pre-orders are available today for €79, and every unit ships on 1 December. Ready to bring calm, adaptable light to your workspace this winter?

    654 tokens in, 526 out (401 of them reasoning) · 11.0 s · $0.0033 · 1 message on Pro · answered by google/gemini-4-carbon via Google AI Studio ·

  5. Argue both sides of free buses

    A hard prompt: “Argue both sides of free buses”, in full.

    Passed: Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    Eliminating bus fares transforms public transit into a true public good, like sidewalks or parks. For working-class families, saving thousands annually unlocks access to better jobs, healthcare, and education, acting as an immediate economic stimulus. Operationally, removing fareboxes speeds up boarding at every stop, making routes faster and more reliable while ending costly fare collection and enforcement. By erasing the price barrier, cities invite residents onto shared transit, easing street congestion, cutting carbon emissions, and building a cleaner, fairer, and more connected metropolis.
    
    Yet universal fare elimination starves transit agencies of vital revenue needed for what riders value most: frequency, reliability, and reach. Drivers shun buses because service is slow and scarce, not over a two-dollar fare; real-world trials show free transit mostly replaces walking and cycling rather than car trips, crowding vehicles without cutting traffic or emissions. Leaving transit wholly reliant on volatile city budgets also invites painful service cuts during downturns. Targeted low-income discounts deliver equity far better while preserving funds to run more buses, more often.

    628 tokens in, 1,466 out (1,251 of them reasoning) · 21.0 s · $0.0080 · 1 message on Pro · answered by google/gemini-4-carbon via Google AI Studio ·

How it compares on writing

Gemini 4 Carbon beside the job's picks among every model. 14 models share the hard-problems pick, Gemini 4 Carbon among them.

Gemini 4 Carbon beside other models on writing
ModelPassedOn ProCost per reply
Gemini 3.8 FlashOur pick: hard problems (shared), best value5 of 5250 a month on Pro$0.0005
DeepSeek V4.1 FlashOur pick: everyday4 of 560 a day on Pro$0.0003
Gemini 4 CarbonOur pick: hard problems (shared)5 of 562 a month on Pro$0.0063
On Pro: Pro's count on each model. Cost: what OpenRouter charged us per reply, on average.

Every limit is published. Paid plans also have a monthly fair-use limit on AI cost: Plus $3.75, Pro $7.50, Max $20, Ultra $42, Studio $85. Using every message on your plan at typical sizes stays under it; very large messages and heavy research use it faster. Every limit, explained.

Gemini 4 Carbon next to each model on writing

Gemini 4 Carbon against each model on the same 5 writing prompts. One run each, through OpenRouter: a wait depends on the provider and the load that day, so a lead under 10% counts as close.

  • Against Claude Fable 5.2: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 6.0× later (21.0 s to 3.5 s), cost 1.8× less, and passed 5 of 5 to its 5.

  • Against Claude Fable 5.1: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 5.1× later (21.0 s to 4.1 s), cost 2.1× less, and passed 5 of 5 to its 4. Only Gemini 4 Carbon passed Argue both sides of free buses.

  • Against Claude Opus 5.5: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 4.3× later (21.0 s to 4.8 s), cost 2.5× less, and passed 5 of 5 to its 5.

  • Against Claude Sonnet 5.5: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 7.8× later (21.0 s to 2.7 s), cost 2.4× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 4. Only Gemini 4 Carbon passed Argue both sides of free buses.

  • Against Claude Sonnet 5: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 5.9× later (21.0 s to 3.6 s), cost 1.7× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 3. Only Gemini 4 Carbon passed Announce a second bakery shop on LinkedIn; A product announcement with five rules.

  • Against Claude Haiku 5.5: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 12.3× later (21.0 s to 1.7 s), cost 47.5× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 3. Only Gemini 4 Carbon passed Rewrite corporate jargon in plain words; Argue both sides of free buses.

  • Against Claude Haiku 4.5: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 12.3× later (21.0 s to 1.7 s), cost 4.8× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 4. Only Gemini 4 Carbon passed A product announcement with five rules.

  • Against GPT-6.2 Astra: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 4.3× later (21.0 s to 4.9 s), cost 1.4× less, and passed 5 of 5 to its 5.

  • Against GPT-6 Astra: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 4.5× later (21.0 s to 4.7 s), cost within 10% of it, and passed 5 of 5 to its 4. Only Gemini 4 Carbon passed Rewrite corporate jargon in plain words.

  • Against GPT-6.2 Sol: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 11.5× later (21.0 s to 1.8 s), cost 2.8× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 5.

  • Against GPT-6.1 Sol: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 3.8× later (21.0 s to 5.5 s), cost 3.3× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 5.

  • Against GPT-6 Sol: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 6.4× later (21.0 s to 3.3 s), cost 4.7× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 5.

  • Against GPT-6.1 Terra: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 5.4× later (21.0 s to 3.9 s), cost 9.6× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 5.

  • Against GPT-6 Luna: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 8.1× later (21.0 s to 2.6 s), cost 112.5× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 3. Only Gemini 4 Carbon passed Rewrite corporate jargon in plain words; Argue both sides of free buses.

  • Against Gemini 4 Argon: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 2.7× later (21.0 s to 7.9 s), cost 4.5× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 4. Only Gemini 4 Carbon passed Argue both sides of free buses.

  • Against Gemini 4 Hydrogen: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 2.7× later (21.0 s to 7.9 s), cost within 10% of it, and passed 5 of 5 to its 5.

  • Against Gemini 3.1 Pro (preview): Gemini 4 Carbon answered 2.8× later (21.0 s to 7.4 s), cost 1.3× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 3. Only Gemini 4 Carbon passed A product announcement with five rules; Argue both sides of free buses.

  • Against Gemini 3.8 Flash: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 6.7× later (21.0 s to 3.1 s), cost 12.8× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 5.

  • Against DeepSeek V4.1 Flash: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 13.5× later (21.0 s to 1.6 s), cost 19.2× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 4. Only Gemini 4 Carbon passed Rewrite corporate jargon in plain words.

  • Against DeepSeek V4 Pro: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 6.3× later (21.0 s to 3.3 s), cost 4.9× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 5.

  • Against Grok 4.7: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 2.5× later (21.0 s to 8.6 s), cost 1.1× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 5.

  • Against Kimi K3.1 Pro: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 3.0× later (21.0 s to 6.9 s), cost 1.3× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 5.

  • Against Kimi K3: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 4.1× later (21.0 s to 5.1 s), cost 1.9× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 4. Only Gemini 4 Carbon passed Argue both sides of free buses.

  • Against GLM 5.3: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 13.8× later (21.0 s to 1.5 s), cost 7.3× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 4. Only Gemini 4 Carbon passed Argue both sides of free buses.

  • Against GLM 5.3 Flash: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 20.5× later (21.0 s to 1.0 s), cost 38.6× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 4. Only Gemini 4 Carbon passed A product announcement with five rules.

  • Against Mistral Large 4: Gemini 4 Carbon answered 2.9× later (21.0 s to 7.2 s), cost 4.3× more, and passed 5 of 5 to its 5.

How these runs were done

Rubric (graded). The grader model scores the reply from 1 to 5 on each published criterion. It passes with an average of 4 or more and no criterion under 3, and only if it also meets the prompt's automatic rules (length, words it must or mustn't use).

The grader is Claude Opus 5.5 at low reasoning effort; its own replies are graded by GPT-6 Astra, so no model grades itself. Its prompt and every rubric are on the methods page.

How the runs were done, and every writing prompt.

Gemini 4 Carbon, and writing, elsewhere

Questions

Is Gemini 4 Carbon good for writing?

In our test runs it passed 5 of 5 writing prompts, tied 1st of the 27 models in llmwise. Every reply is on this page, so you can judge them yourself.

How many of my messages does a writing reply from Gemini 4 Carbon use?

1 message each on Pro, where it has 62 a month on Pro. The price of a message is fixed and shown before you send it, however long the reply.

How were these runs done?

The same way for every model: each prompt sent through llmwise's own pipeline, each reply checked the same way. The methods page has every prompt and how each is scored.

Claude, GPT, Gemini, DeepSeek, Grok, Kimi, GLM, and Mistral, in one chat.

See what a message costs before you send it. Every plan is month to month: cancel in two clicks. Sign in with an email link, no password.