1. Persona, task, context and format
Everyday · 4 of 4 passed
Google's own guide for Gemini builds prompts from a persona, a task, context and a format; this one has all four.
You are a [your role]. Draft [what you need] for [your audience] using the notes below. They care most about [what they care about]. Limit it to [the format]. [paste your notes]
How we filled it in and checked the replies
You are a program manager. Draft an executive summary email for our leadership team using the notes below. They care most about revenue against target and the two biggest risks. Limit it to a subject line and at most 5 bullet points. Q3: revenue $4.1M vs $3.8M target. New customers 212 (target 250). Churn 3.1%, down from 3.9%. Risks: our largest client (18% of revenue) renews in December and is reviewing vendors; the mobile app rewrite is 6 weeks late. Hiring: 4 of 6 roles filled.
- What they care about: Leads with revenue against target and names both risks (the December renewal, the late app).
- Format: A subject line and no more than five bullet points.
- Accurate: Every number matches the notes.
- Automatic rules: includes “4.1”; includes “3.8”; includes “December”; includes “mobile”.
Gemini 3.1 Pro
PassedGraded 5.0 of 5 on average (lowest 5).
**Subject: Q3 Executive Summary - Revenue Exceeds Target & Key Risks** * **Revenue Beat:** Q3 revenue reached $4.1M, successfully exceeding our $3.8M target. * **Key Risk - Client Retention:** Our largest client (18% of revenue) is reviewing vendors ahead of their December renewal. * **Key Risk - Project Delay:** The mobile app rewrite is currently 6 weeks behind schedule. * **Customer Metrics:** Churn improved significantly to 3.1% (down from 3.9%), softening the impact of missing our new customer target (212 added vs. 250 target). * **Hiring Progress:** 4 of the 6 open headcount roles have been filled.
1 message on Pro · $0.0056 to run · 7.7 s · 857 tokens out
Gemini 3.8 Flash
PassedGraded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).
**Subject:** Executive Summary: Q3 Performance & Key Risk Overview * **Revenue Outperformance:** Delivered $4.1M in Q3 revenue, exceeding our $3.8M target despite missing the new customer acquisition goal (212 vs. 250 target). * **Improved Retention:** Churn dropped significantly to 3.1% (down from 3.9% last quarter), helping drive strong net revenue. * **Top Risk — Key Account Renewal:** Our largest client (representing 18% of total revenue) renews in December and is actively evaluating competing vendors. * **Top Risk — Product Delivery:** The mobile app rewrite is currently delayed by 6 weeks, impacting our product roadmap. * **Team Scaling:** Headcount expansion is progressing steadily, with 4 of 6 open positions filled.
1 message on Pro · $0.0005 to run · 2.0 s · 175 tokens out
GPT-6 Luna
PassedGraded 5.0 of 5 on average (lowest 5).
**Subject: Q3 Executive Update: Revenue Above Target; Two Key Risks** - Revenue was **$4.1M**, **$300K (8%) above** the $3.8M target. - New customers were **212 vs. 250 target**; churn improved to **3.1% from 3.9%**. - **Renewal risk:** Our largest client represents 18% of revenue and is reviewing vendors ahead of its December renewal. - **Delivery risk:** The mobile app rewrite is **six weeks behind schedule**. - Hiring is **4 of 6 roles filled**.
1 message on Pro · $0.0001 to run · 1.9 s · 130 tokens out
Claude Sonnet 5
PassedGraded 5.0 of 5 on average (lowest 5).
**Subject: Q3 Recap: Revenue Beat, Two Risks Need Attention** - Revenue hit $4.1M vs. $3.8M target (+8%); churn improved to 3.1% (from 3.9%). - New customer adds came in light at 212 vs. 250 target. - **Risk 1:** Largest client (18% of revenue) is up for renewal in December and actively reviewing other vendors. - **Risk 2:** Mobile app rewrite is 6 weeks behind schedule. - Hiring at 4 of 6 roles filled; remaining gaps could affect delivery timelines.
1 message on Pro · $0.0035 to run · 10.1 s · 223 tokens out