Skip to content

Prompts · Teachers

AI prompts for teachers, tested with every reply

10 prompts for teachers, each run on GPT-6 Luna, GPT-6 Sol, Gemini 3.8 Flash, and Claude Haiku 4.5: 36 of 40 replies passed our checks. Below, each prompt with its replies side by side: whether each passed, what it counted as on Pro and what it cost to run. 3 of the 10 prompts split the models.

A real reply from these prompts' runs

GPT-6 Luna

Make a 45-minute lesson plan on equivalent fractions for a Year 5 class: a learning objective, a warm-up, the main activity, a check for understanding and an exit ticket, each with its minutes, adding up to exactly 45-minute.

GPT-6 Luna · passed our check · September 28, 2026

## Year 5 Lesson Plan: Equivalent Fractions (45 minutes)

**Learning objective — 2 minutes**  
Students will recognise and generate equivalent fractions by multiplying or dividing the numerator and denominator by the same number.

| Lesson part | Minutes | Activity |
|---|---:|---|
| **Warm-up** | 8 | Display fraction pairs (e.g., \(1/2\) and \(2/4\), \(2/3\) and \(3/5\)). Students decide which pairs are equivalent and explain how they know. |
| **Main activity** | 22 | Model equivalent fractions using fraction strips or diagrams, then show how multiplying or dividing both parts by the same number keeps the value unchanged. Students complete a differentiated task: fill missing numerators or denominators, generate equivalent fractions, and explain their strategy. |
| **Check for understanding** | 8 | Students solve three questions on mini-whiteboards: identify an equivalent fraction, complete a missing value (e.g., \(3/4 = \square/12\)), and explain why \(2/6\) is equivalent to \(1/3\). Address any misconceptions. |
| **Exit ticket** | 5 | Students independently write two fractions equivalent to \(3/5\) and explain the rule they used. |

**Total: 2 + 8 + 22 + 8 + 5 = 45 minutes**

Ask your own question: sign up free for 5 messages on 14 of the models, no card.

Start free

Test runs checked . Updated .

Short answer

GPT-6 Luna and GPT-6 Sol passed the most of these prompts: 10 of 10 each, in our runs on September 28, 2026. The clearest split: “Mark an answer against a mark scheme”, passed by GPT-6 Luna, GPT-6 Sol, and Gemini 3.8 Flash and failed by Claude Haiku 4.5.

What these prompts are for

Prompts for planning, teaching and assessing: a lesson plan whose minutes add up, one task at three levels, a marking rubric, a quiz built on misconceptions, feedback to a student, a trip letter to parents, a concept at three ages, discussion questions beyond recall, marking against a mark scheme and a fill-in-the-blanks worksheet.

We checked what matters in a classroom: the timings, the facts, and whether the marking follows the scheme.

The prompts at a glance

Every prompt on every model, as our check scored the reply. Tap a prompt to jump to it and read the replies.

Every prompt on every model: passed or failed
PromptGPT-6 LunaGPT-6 SolGemini 3.8 FlashClaude Haiku 4.5
A lesson plan whose minutes add upPassedPassedPassedPassed
One task at three levelsPassedPassedPassedPassed
A marking rubric for an assignmentPassedPassedPassedPassed
A quiz with the misconceptions spelled outPassedPassedPassedFailed
Kind, specific feedback on student workPassedPassedPassedPassed
A trip letter to parentsPassedPassedFailedFailed
One concept at three agesPassedPassedPassedPassed
Discussion questions beyond recallPassedPassedPassedPassed
Mark an answer against a mark schemePassedPassedPassedFailed
A fill-in-the-blanks worksheetPassedPassedPassedPassed
Passed10 of 1010 of 109 of 107 of 10
Each model on these prompts
ModelPassedEach reply on ProCost per replyTime per reply
GPT-6 LunaOpenAI10 of 101 message on Pro$0.00012.9 s
GPT-6 SolOpenAI10 of 101 message on Pro$0.00173.1 s
Gemini 3.8 FlashGoogle9 of 101 message on Pro$0.00092.4 s
Claude Haiku 4.5Anthropic7 of 101 message on Pro$0.00203.9 s
Passed: of the prompts each model answered, how many replies passed their check. Each reply on Pro: what one of these messages counts as on llmwise's Pro plan. Cost: what OpenRouter charged us per reply, on average; in llmwise you pay per message, not per token.

Where the models split

The same prompt, a pass on one model and a fail on another: what failed, in the check's words and the grader's.

  • Mark an answer against a mark scheme

    Passed: GPT-6 Luna, GPT-6 Sol, and Gemini 3.8 Flash. Failed: Claude Haiku 4.5.

    The scheme gives the third mark only for both products, glucose and oxygen. The student named glucose alone; Claude Haiku 4.5 called that "partially met" and gave the mark anyway, for 2 out of 3. The other three gave 1.

    • Why Claude Haiku 4.5 failed: Final answer 2 marks; expected 1.

  • A trip letter to parents

    Passed: GPT-6 Luna and GPT-6 Sol. Failed: Gemini 3.8 Flash and Claude Haiku 4.5.

    • Why Gemini 3.8 Flash failed: Graded 3.7 of 5 on average (lowest 2).

      The grader: “The reply includes every required detail and is easy to scan, but it invents several things: a water bottle and backpack, a 'strictly nut-free school' policy, a consent form deadline that reuses the payment date, and 'to secure your child's place'.”
    • Why Claude Haiku 4.5 failed: Graded 3.7 of 5 on average (lowest 2).

      The grader: “All details appear in a scannable bulleted layout, but the reply invents a 7 November deadline for returning the consent form (the task gave that date only for payment) and adds filler about interactive exhibits, and the parent actions are split between the list and a separate sentence.”
  • A quiz with the misconceptions spelled out

    Passed: GPT-6 Luna, GPT-6 Sol, and Gemini 3.8 Flash. Failed: Claude Haiku 4.5.

    • Why Claude Haiku 4.5 failed: Graded 3.7 of 5 on average (lowest 2).

      The grader: “All five keyed answers are correct, but many misconception labels just restate the distractor or describe errors pupils don't really make (Q1 C 'requires a solid state', Q5 A 'only happens at the surface', Q4 B puddle), and the content fits Year 6 apart from 'sublimation' being a stretch.”

The 10 prompts, with every reply

Copy a prompt, replace the parts in [brackets] with your own, and send it to any model. Below each, the replies we got with our example filled in.

1. A lesson plan whose minutes add up

Hard · 4 of 4 passed

Minutes that must add up keep a plan realistic, and they're easy to check.

The prompt: replace the parts in [brackets]

Make a [length] lesson plan on [your topic] for [your class]: a learning objective, a warm-up, the main activity, a check for understanding and an exit ticket, each with its minutes, adding up to exactly [length].

Open in llmwise
How we filled it in and checked the replies
Make a 45-minute lesson plan on equivalent fractions for a Year 5 class: a learning objective, a warm-up, the main activity, a check for understanding and an exit ticket, each with its minutes, adding up to exactly 45-minute.
  • Adds up: The minutes add up to exactly 45.
  • Complete: Objective, warm-up, main activity, check for understanding and exit ticket.
  • Right level: Suits Year 5 and equivalent fractions.
  • GPT-6 Luna

    Passed

    Graded 5.0 of 5 on average (lowest 5).

    ## Year 5 Lesson Plan: Equivalent Fractions (45 minutes)
    
    **Learning objective — 2 minutes**  
    Students will recognise and generate equivalent fractions by multiplying or dividing the numerator and denominator by the same number.
    
    | Lesson part | Minutes | Activity |
    |---|---:|---|
    | **Warm-up** | 8 | Display fraction pairs (e.g., \(1/2\) and \(2/4\), \(2/3\) and \(3/5\)). Students decide which pairs are equivalent and explain how they know. |
    | **Main activity** | 22 | Model equivalent fractions using fraction strips or diagrams, then show how multiplying or dividing both parts by the same number keeps the value unchanged. Students complete a differentiated task: fill missing numerators or denominators, generate equivalent fractions, and explain their strategy. |
    | **Check for understanding** | 8 | Students solve three questions on mini-whiteboards: identify an equivalent fraction, complete a missing value (e.g., \(3/4 = \square/12\)), and explain why \(2/6\) is equivalent to \(1/3\). Address any misconceptions. |
    | **Exit ticket** | 5 | Students independently write two fractions equivalent to \(3/5\) and explain the rule they used. |
    
    **Total: 2 + 8 + 22 + 8 + 5 = 45 minutes**

    1 message on Pro · $0.0001 to run · 3.8 s · 295 tokens out

  • GPT-6 Sol

    Passed

    Graded 5.0 of 5 on average (lowest 5).

    ### Year 5 lesson plan: Equivalent fractions (45 minutes)
    
    | Part | Minutes | Activity |
    |---|---:|---|
    | **Learning objective** | **3** | Share the goal: *I can use models and multiplication or division to find and explain equivalent fractions.* Show \(1/2 = 2/4\) with two equal-sized fraction strips. |
    | **Warm-up** | **7** | Display \(1/2\), \(2/4\), \(1/3\) and \(3/6\). Pupils discuss in pairs which show the same amount and explain how they know. |
    | **Main activity** | **25** | **Model (5 min):** Fold or draw fraction strips to show \(1/3 = 2/6 = 3/9\). Link this to multiplying the numerator and denominator by the same number. **Pairs (12 min):** Use strips or diagrams to find three equivalents each for \(1/2\), \(2/3\) and \(3/4\), then record the number patterns. **Independent (8 min):** Complete missing-number equations, such as \(2/5 = \square/10\), and explain one answer in words. |
    | **Check for understanding** | **7** | Ask pupils to solve \(3/4 = \square/12\) on mini-whiteboards and explain their method. Address the misconception that changing only the numerator makes an equivalent fraction. |
    | **Exit ticket** | **3** | Each pupil writes one fraction equivalent to \(2/3\) and one sentence explaining why it is equivalent. Collect to plan the next lesson. |
    
    **Total: 45 minutes.**

    1 message on Pro · $0.0025 to run · 5.3 s · 431 tokens out

  • Gemini 3.8 Flash

    Passed

    Graded 5.0 of 5 on average (lowest 5).

    ### Year 5 Lesson Plan: Equivalent Fractions (45 Minutes)
    
    **Learning Objective:**  
    Pupils will be able to identify, generate, and explain equivalent fractions by multiplying or dividing the numerator and denominator by the same non-zero number.
    
    ---
    
    ### 1. Warm-Up: Fraction Recall & Strip Folding (7 minutes)
    * **Activity:** Give each student a strip of paper. 
      1. Fold in half, label $\frac{1}{2}$, and shade one side.
      2. Fold in half again to create fourths. Ask: *"How many fourths equal $\frac{1}{2}$?"* ($\frac{2}{4}$).
      3. Fold once more to create eighths. Ask: *"How many eighths equal $\frac{1}{2}$?"* ($\frac{4}{8}$).
    * **Discussion:** Emphasise that the shaded area never changed size, only the number of equal parts did. Introduce the term **equivalent fractions**.
    
    ---
    
    ### 2. Main Activity: The Multiplier Rule & "Fraction Dominoes" (23 minutes)
    * **Direct Instruction (8 mins):** 
      * Demonstrate on the board using a visual bar model that multiplying the top (numerator) and bottom (denominator) by the same number splits parts equally without changing the value:
        $$\frac{2}{3} \times \frac{2}{2} = \frac{4}{6}, \quad \frac{2}{3} \times \frac{3}{3} = \frac{6}{9}$$
      * State the rule: *"Whatever you do to the numerator, you must do to the denominator."*
    * **Guided & Independent Practice (15 mins):**
      * Pupils work in pairs on **Fraction Dominoes / Matching Cards**.
      * Each pair receives cards with fractions (e.g., $\frac{1}{3}$, $\frac{2}{6}$, $\frac{3}{9}$, $\frac{4}{12}$) and visual representations.
      * Task: Match cards representing equivalent values and record the rule used in their books (e.g., *"$\frac{1}{3} = \frac{3}{9}$ because both were multiplied by 3"*).
    
    ---
    
    ### 3. Check for Understanding: Mini-Whiteboard Challenge (10 minutes)
    * Project three quick-fire questions on the board for students to answer on individual whiteboards (show on "3, 2, 1, reveal"):
      1. Complete the missing number: $\frac{3}{5} = \frac{\square}{20}$ *(Answer: 12)*
      2. True or False: $\frac{2}{4}$ is equivalent to $\frac{6}{10}$. Explain why. *(Answer: False; $2 \times 3 = 6$, but $4 \times 3 \neq 10$)*
      3. Find two fractions equivalent to $\frac{5}{6}$. *(Open-ended: $\frac{10}{12}$, $\frac{15}{18}$, etc.)*
    * Address any misconceptions immediately.
    
    ---
    
    ### 4. Exit Ticket: Quick Check (5 minutes)
    * Each student completes an individual slip before leaving:
      1. Fill in the blank: $\frac{4}{7} = \frac{8}{\square}$
      2. Circle the fraction that is **not** equivalent to $\frac{1}{4}$:  
         $$\frac{2}{8} \quad \frac{3}{12} \quad \frac{4}{15} \quad \frac{5}{20}$$
    
    ---
    
    **Total Time Breakdown:**  
    $7\text{ min} + 23\text{ min} + 10\text{ min} + 5\text{ min} = \mathbf{45\text{ minutes}}$

    1 message on Pro · $0.0017 to run · 4.3 s · 840 tokens out

  • Claude Haiku 4.5

    Passed

    Graded 5.0 of 5 on average (lowest 5).

    # Year 5 Equivalent Fractions Lesson Plan (45 minutes)
    
    ## Learning Objective
    Students will understand that equivalent fractions represent the same amount and be able to generate and identify equivalent fractions using visual models and multiplication/division strategies.
    
    ---
    
    ## Warm-Up: Fraction Review (5 minutes)
    - Display three simple fractions on the board: 1/2, 1/4, 3/4
    - Ask students to draw or shade these fractions using circle diagrams
    - Quick verbal check: "What do we call the number on top? On the bottom?"
    - Establish prior knowledge before introducing equivalence
    
    ---
    
    ## Main Activity: Discovering Equivalent Fractions (28 minutes)
    
    **Part 1: Visual Exploration (12 minutes)**
    - Distribute fraction strip or circle templates
    - Show 1/2 shaded, then ask: "Can we make the same amount using different pieces?"
    - Demonstrate 2/4 and 3/6 alongside 1/2
    - Students create their own equivalent fractions using manipulatives (strips or circle models)
    - Display findings on a chart: 1/2 = 2/4 = 3/6
    
    **Part 2: Finding the Pattern (10 minutes)**
    - Introduce the rule: "When we multiply (or divide) the top AND bottom by the same number, we get an equivalent fraction"
    - Model with 1/2: multiply top and bottom by 2 → 2/4; by 3 → 3/6; by 5 → 5/10
    - Work through 2 more examples as a class (e.g., 1/3, 2/5)
    - Students try two examples independently with teacher support
    
    **Part 3: Practice (6 minutes)**
    - Guided practice: Complete 3 equivalent fraction problems together
    - Students identify the multiplier used (e.g., 2/3 → 6/9: "What did we multiply by?")
    
    ---
    
    ## Check for Understanding (7 minutes)
    - **Activity**: Equivalent Fraction Matching Game
    - Display cards with fractions and ask students to match equivalents
    - Call on different students to explain their matches: "Why is 3/4 the same as 6/8?"
    - Observe responses to assess misconceptions
    
    ---
    
    ## Exit Ticket (5 minutes)
    Students complete on mini whiteboards or paper:
    1. Draw or shade 2/3
    2. Find one equivalent fraction for 2/3 and show your working
    3. Write one thing they learned today about equivalent fractions
    
    Collect to inform next lesson planning.
    
    ---
    
    **Total: 5 + 28 + 7 + 5 = 45 minutes**

    1 message on Pro · $0.0036 to run · 7.7 s · 628 tokens out

2. One task at three levels

Everyday · 4 of 4 passed

Three versions of one task keep the class together while meeting each student where they are.

The prompt: replace the parts in [brackets]

Differentiate this task three ways, support, core and stretch, with a sentence on who each is for. Task: [your task]

Open in llmwise
How we filled it in and checked the replies
Differentiate this task three ways, support, core and stretch, with a sentence on who each is for.

Task: Write a paragraph explaining why the Romans built roads, using two pieces of evidence.
  • Three levels: Support, core and stretch versions of the same task.
  • Real scaffolds: Support adds structure (sentence starters, a word bank); stretch adds depth.
  • Who it's for: A sentence on who each suits.
  • GPT-6 Luna

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    - **Support:** Use the sentence starters “The Romans built roads to ___” and “One piece of evidence is ___.” Add a second piece of evidence, then combine your ideas into a paragraph. **For learners who benefit from prompts and help organizing their ideas.**
    - **Core:** Write a paragraph explaining why the Romans built roads, using two relevant pieces of evidence to support your explanation. **For learners ready to complete the task independently.**
    - **Stretch:** Write a paragraph explaining why the Romans built roads, using two pieces of evidence and explaining how each supports your answer; consider more than one purpose for the roads. **For learners ready to develop a more detailed, nuanced explanation.**

    1 message on Pro · $0.0001 to run · 2.1 s · 144 tokens out

  • GPT-6 Sol

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    - **Support:** For students who need help organising their ideas. Complete a paragraph using the frame: “The Romans built roads because ____. One piece of evidence is ____, which shows ____. Another piece of evidence is ____, which shows ____.” Use two facts from your class materials.
    
    - **Core:** For students ready to write independently. Write a paragraph explaining why the Romans built roads, using two pieces of evidence to support your explanation.
    
    - **Stretch:** For students ready to analyse further. Write a paragraph explaining why the Romans built roads, using two pieces of evidence, and decide which reason was most important. Justify your choice.

    1 message on Pro · $0.0012 to run · 2.4 s · 164 tokens out

  • Gemini 3.8 Flash

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    **Support**
    * **Task:** Using the provided sentence starters and a word bank containing two facts, write a short paragraph explaining two reasons why the Romans built roads.
    * **Target:** For learners who struggle with writing structure or information retrieval and need scaffolding to express their understanding.
    
    **Core**
    * **Task:** Write a paragraph explaining why the Romans built roads, including at least two specific pieces of historical evidence to back up your points.
    * **Target:** For learners working at grade level who can independently structure a basic informational paragraph using supporting details.
    
    **Stretch**
    * **Task:** Write an analytical paragraph evaluating the primary motive behind Roman road construction (e.g., military control vs. trade expansion), justifying your argument with two distinct pieces of evidence and explaining how they connect.
    * **Target:** For high-achieving learners who are ready to move beyond recall into historical evaluation and synthesis.

    1 message on Pro · $0.0005 to run · 1.8 s · 186 tokens out

  • Claude Haiku 4.5

    Passed

    Graded 4.0 of 5 on average (lowest 3).

    # Differentiated Task: Roman Roads
    
    **SUPPORT** (for students needing scaffolding)
    Write a paragraph explaining why the Romans built roads. Here are two reasons to choose from: to move armies quickly, or to trade goods. Pick one reason and explain it in 3-4 sentences.
    *For learners who need sentence frames, reduced writing load, or pre-selected evidence.*
    
    **CORE** (for students at grade level)
    Write a paragraph explaining why the Romans built roads, using two pieces of evidence from your notes or textbook to support your answer.
    *For learners working at the expected standard with access to resources.*
    
    **STRETCH** (for advanced learners)
    Write a paragraph explaining why the Romans built roads, using two specific pieces of evidence (such as examples of famous roads, historical data, or primary sources). Then explain how their road system gave them an advantage over other civilizations.
    *For learners ready to synthesize multiple sources, make comparisons, and think analytically about cause and effect.*

    1 message on Pro · $0.0015 to run · 3.4 s · 225 tokens out

3. A marking rubric for an assignment

Everyday · 4 of 4 passed

Asking for descriptors a student can check turns a rubric from a grading tool into a learning tool.

The prompt: replace the parts in [brackets]

Make a marking rubric for [the assignment] as a table: 4 criteria, 4 levels each, with descriptors a student could check their work against.

Open in llmwise
How we filled it in and checked the replies
Make a marking rubric for a Year 9 persuasive speech about a local issue as a table: 4 criteria, 4 levels each, with descriptors a student could check their work against.
  • Four by four: A table of 4 criteria and 4 levels.
  • Observable: Descriptors describe what's in the work, not vague praise.
  • Fitting: Criteria fit a persuasive speech.
  • GPT-6 Luna

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    | Criterion | Beginning | Developing | Proficient | Advanced |
    |---|---|---|---|---|
    | **Position and local relevance** | ☐ I mention a local issue, but my position is unclear or I don’t explain why it matters here. | ☐ I state a position and give a simple reason the issue matters to our community. | ☐ I clearly state my position and explain why the issue matters to local people. | ☐ I present a convincing, nuanced position and show a strong understanding of how the issue affects different people in our community. |
    | **Reasons and evidence** | ☐ I give few reasons, or my claims are hard to follow and unsupported. | ☐ I give at least two relevant reasons, with some examples or evidence. | ☐ I support my reasons with relevant examples, facts, or evidence and explain how they back up my position. | ☐ I use well-chosen, credible evidence and examples, explain their significance, and address a possible counterargument. |
    | **Persuasive language and speech structure** | ☐ My ideas are difficult to follow, and I use few persuasive techniques. | ☐ My speech has a basic beginning, middle, and ending, with some persuasive language. | ☐ I organise my speech clearly and use persuasive techniques—such as emotive language, rhetorical questions, or repetition—to strengthen my case. | ☐ I shape my speech purposefully, use persuasive techniques effectively, and build to a memorable conclusion or call to action. |
    | **Speaking and audience engagement** | ☐ I am difficult to hear or understand, or I rely heavily on reading my speech. | ☐ I can be heard and understood most of the time; I sometimes look up or vary my voice. | ☐ I speak clearly at a suitable pace and volume, make regular eye contact, and use expression to engage the audience. | ☐ I deliver confidently and expressively, using voice, pauses, and eye contact to hold the audience’s attention and make my message compelling. |

    1 message on Pro · $0.0001 to run · 5.4 s · 423 tokens out

  • GPT-6 Sol

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    ### Year 9 persuasive speech rubric: A local issue
    
    | Criterion | Level 4 — Strong | Level 3 — Effective | Level 2 — Developing | Level 1 — Beginning |
    |---|---|---|---|---|
    | **Position and local relevance** | I clearly state what should change, explain why it matters in our community, and propose a realistic action. | I state my position, connect it to our community, and suggest an action. | My position or local connection is unclear, or my suggested action is vague. | I do not make a clear argument about a local issue or suggest an action. |
    | **Reasons and evidence** | I give several distinct reasons, support them with specific, credible evidence, and explain how the evidence backs my argument. | I give clear reasons and relevant evidence, with some explanation. | I give reasons, but the evidence is limited, general, or not clearly explained. | I mainly give opinions without reasons or supporting evidence. |
    | **Structure and persuasion** | My opening grabs attention; ideas flow logically; persuasive techniques suit my audience; and my ending makes a clear call to action. | My speech has a clear opening, organised points, persuasive language, and a call to action. | Some parts are organised, but points may repeat or jump around; persuasive language or the ending needs work. | My speech is hard to follow and has little persuasive language or no clear ending. |
    | **Speaking and audience engagement** | I speak clearly at a suitable pace, use pauses and emphasis for effect, and regularly look at the audience. | I can be heard and understood, use some expression, and look at the audience at times. | I sometimes speak too quickly, quietly, or without expression, and rely heavily on notes. | I am difficult to hear or understand and mostly read directly from my notes. |

    1 message on Pro · $0.0027 to run · 5.0 s · 455 tokens out

  • Gemini 3.8 Flash

    Passed

    Graded 4.3 of 5 on average (lowest 3).

    ### Year 9 Persuasive Speech Rubric: Local Issue
    
    | Criteria | Level 1: Beginning | Level 2: Developing | Level 3: Proficient | Level 4: Advanced |
    | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |
    | **1. Argument & Local Relevance** | • The topic is too broad or does not clearly focus on a local issue.<br>• Main point/opinion is unclear.<br>• Few or no specific local examples or facts are used. | • The issue is local, but the focus drifts at times.<br>• Stance is stated but lacks depth.<br>• Includes 1–2 general local facts or examples, but some claims lack support. | • Focuses clearly on a specific, relevant local community issue.<br>• Stance is clear, focused, and maintained throughout.<br>• Supported by relevant local evidence, facts, or real-life community examples. | • Deeply engages with a specific, urgent local issue.<br>• Presents a compelling, nuanced central argument.<br>• Expertly integrates well-researched local data, interviews/quotes, and specific community impact. |
    | **2. Persuasive Devices & Language** | • Relies mostly on simple statements or unsubstantiated opinions.<br>• Very few persuasive techniques used.<br>• Tone may be overly casual or inappropriate for a speech. | • Uses basic persuasive techniques (e.g., rhetorical questions, repetition), but they feel forced.<br>• Vocabulary is simple and occasionally persuasive.<br>• Tone is generally appropriate. | • Uses a balanced variety of persuasive techniques (e.g., rule of three, emotive language, appeals to logic/fairness).<br>• Vocabulary is deliberately chosen to influence the audience.<br>• Tone is confident and consistently persuasive. | • Seamlessly weaves sophisticated rhetorical devices (e.g., call-to-action, ethos/pathos/logos, antithesis) to strongly move the audience.<br>• Rich, powerful vocabulary.<br>• Masterful control of tone tailored to the local audience. |
    | **3. Structure & Organisation** | • Lacks a clear beginning, middle, or end.<br>• Ideas jump around without clear paragraphing or flow.<br>• Abrupt or missing conclusion. | • Has an introduction and conclusion, but they are brief or formulaic.<br>• Points follow a recognizable order, though transitions between ideas are abrupt. | • Engaging introduction with a hook and clear thesis.<br>• Logical progression of arguments using signposting/connectives.<br>• Strong conclusion that summarizes points and includes a call to action. | • Captivating introduction that immediately hooks the audience.<br>• Flawless flow between points; arguments build logically and powerfully toward a climax.<br>• Memorable, decisive conclusion with an actionable community solution. |
    | **4. Delivery & Engagement** | • Reads entirely from notes/cue cards with little eye contact.<br>• Speaks too quietly, too fast, or in a flat monotone.<br>• Rigid posture or distracting fidgeting. | • Relies heavily on notes; occasional eye contact.<br>• Volume and pace are adequate, but lacks expressive vocal variety.<br>• Body language is mostly still or hesitant. | • Uses cue cards effectively while maintaining frequent eye contact with different sections of the room.<br>• Clear voice, good projection, and natural variation in pace and pitch.<br>• Purposeful posture and natural gestures. | • Uses notes minimally or solely for prompts; holds continuous, commanding eye contact.<br>• Dynamic vocal variety (deliberate pauses, emphasis, pitch) to heighten emotional impact.<br>• Confident, purposeful body language and physical presence. |

    1 message on Pro · $0.0016 to run · 4.3 s · 791 tokens out

  • Claude Haiku 4.5

    Passed

    Graded 4.3 of 5 on average (lowest 3).

    # Year 9 Persuasive Speech Rubric: Local Issue
    
    | **Criterion** | **Excellent (4)** | **Good (3)** | **Developing (2)** | **Beginning (1)** |
    |---|---|---|---|---|
    | **Argument Clarity & Logic** | Position is crystal clear and stated early. Arguments flow logically with smooth connections between ideas. Each point directly supports the main claim. | Position is clear and stated early. Most arguments support the position logically, with mostly smooth connections between ideas. | Position is somewhat unclear or takes time to identify. Some arguments support the position; connections between ideas are weak or hard to follow. | Position is unclear or absent. Arguments are disorganized or don't support the position. Hard to follow the logic. |
    | **Use of Evidence & Examples** | Includes multiple specific, relevant local examples or statistics. Evidence is well-explained and directly reinforces each argument. Sources feel credible. | Includes relevant local examples or evidence for most arguments. Evidence generally supports the position, though some links could be clearer. | Includes some local examples or evidence, but they may be vague or partially relevant. Limited explanation of how evidence supports the argument. | Little to no local evidence provided, or evidence is irrelevant or unexplained. |
    | **Audience Engagement & Persuasive Technique** | Uses varied persuasive techniques (e.g., emotional appeal, rhetorical questions, direct address) effectively and naturally. Language choices engage the audience. Acknowledges counterarguments. | Uses at least two persuasive techniques that generally work well. Mostly engages the audience. May briefly acknowledge an opposing view. | Uses one persuasive technique, or techniques feel forced. Limited audience engagement. Does not acknowledge other perspectives. | No clear persuasive techniques used. Audience engagement is minimal or absent. Ignores other viewpoints. |
    | **Delivery & Structure** | Well-organized with strong introduction and conclusion. Pacing is natural and confident. Eye contact and tone enhance the message. Speaks clearly throughout. | Organized with clear introduction and conclusion. Pacing is mostly natural. Generally good eye contact and appropriate tone. Speech is mostly clear. | Some organizational issues; introduction or conclusion is weak. Pacing is uneven or rushed. Limited eye contact or tone varies awkwardly. Some unclear sections. | Poorly organized; introduction/conclusion missing or unclear. Pacing is inconsistent. Minimal eye contact; tone is monotone or inappropriate. Hard to understand in places. |
    
    **How to use this rubric:** Review each criterion and identify which level best describes your work. Aim for "Good" or "Excellent" in each area.

    1 message on Pro · $0.0034 to run · 6.9 s · 595 tokens out

4. A quiz with the misconceptions spelled out

Everyday · 3 of 4 passed

Wrong options built on real misconceptions tell you what a student got wrong, not just that they did.

The prompt: replace the parts in [brackets]

Write 5 multiple-choice questions on [your topic] for [your class], with the answer key and, for each wrong option, the misconception it catches.

Open in llmwise
How we filled it in and checked the replies
Write 5 multiple-choice questions on the water cycle for Year 6, with the answer key and, for each wrong option, the misconception it catches.
  • Correct: Every keyed answer is right.
  • Real misconceptions: Each wrong option matches a real misconception.
  • Level: Suits Year 6.
  • GPT-6 Luna

    Passed

    Graded 4.3 of 5 on average (lowest 3).

    ## Water Cycle: Multiple-Choice Questions (Year 6)
    
    **1. What happens during evaporation?**  
    A. Water vapour cools and forms tiny droplets.  
    B. Liquid water is warmed and changes into water vapour.  
    C. Water falls from clouds as rain.  
    D. Water soaks into the ground.
    
    **2. What causes most water to evaporate from oceans and lakes?**  
    A. Heat from the Sun  
    B. The pull of gravity  
    C. Wind turning water into ice  
    D. Plants releasing water vapour
    
    **3. How do clouds form?**  
    A. Water vapour cools and condenses into tiny water droplets or ice crystals.  
    B. Rain rises from the ground and gathers in the sky.  
    C. The Sun turns clouds into water vapour.  
    D. Wind breaks large drops of water into smaller clouds.
    
    **4. Which is an example of precipitation?**  
    A. Water vapour rising from a lake  
    B. Water soaking into soil  
    C. Rain falling from a cloud  
    D. Water vapour forming a cloud
    
    **5. What is transpiration?**  
    A. Water flowing over the land into rivers  
    B. Plants releasing water vapour from their leaves  
    C. Water changing into ice in a cloud  
    D. Water vapour changing into liquid water
    
    ## Answer key and misconceptions
    
    | Question | Correct answer | Misconceptions caught by the wrong options |
    |---|---|---|
    | 1 | **B** | **A:** Confuses evaporation with condensation. **C:** Confuses evaporation with precipitation. **D:** Confuses evaporation with infiltration (water soaking into the ground). |
    | 2 | **A** | **B:** Thinks gravity, rather than heat, causes evaporation. **C:** Confuses evaporation with freezing. **D:** Confuses evaporation with transpiration, which is water released by plants. |
    | 3 | **A** | **B:** Thinks rain rises to make clouds. **C:** Reverses condensation and evaporation. **D:** Thinks wind alone forms clouds, rather than cooling and condensation. |
    | 4 | **C** | **A:** Confuses evaporation with precipitation. **B:** Confuses infiltration with precipitation. **D:** Confuses condensation with precipitation. |
    | 5 | **B** | **A:** Confuses surface runoff with transpiration. **C:** Confuses transpiration with freezing. **D:** Confuses transpiration with condensation. |

    1 message on Pro · $0.0001 to run · 5.2 s · 525 tokens out

  • GPT-6 Sol

    Passed

    Graded 4.3 of 5 on average (lowest 3).

    ## Water cycle: Year 6 multiple-choice questions
    
    **1. What happens when the Sun warms water in a lake?**  
    A. The water freezes.  
    B. Some liquid water changes into water vapour.  
    C. The water changes into clouds immediately.  
    D. The water disappears forever.
    
    **2. How do clouds form?**  
    A. Water vapour cools and condenses into tiny water droplets.  
    B. Rain rises from the ground.  
    C. Water vapour turns into smoke.  
    D. The Sun makes new water inside the sky.
    
    **3. Which of these is an example of precipitation?**  
    A. Water soaking into soil  
    B. Water vapour rising from the sea  
    C. Snow falling from a cloud  
    D. Water droplets forming on a cold window
    
    **4. How can water from a puddle eventually reach a river?**  
    A. It can soak into the ground and later flow into the river.  
    B. It must turn into ice before it can move.  
    C. It can only reach a river by falling as rain again.  
    D. It is used up by the ground and cannot reach the river.
    
    **5. What do plants contribute to the water cycle?**  
    A. They release water vapour into the air through their leaves.  
    B. They turn water into sunlight.  
    C. They stop water from evaporating anywhere nearby.  
    D. They create new water from soil.
    
    ## Answer key and misconceptions
    
    | Q | Answer | What each wrong option reveals |
    |---|---|---|
    | 1 | **B** | **A:** Confuses heating with freezing. **C:** Skips the evaporation and condensation stages. **D:** Thinks evaporated water no longer exists. |
    | 2 | **A** | **B:** Thinks rain moves upwards to make clouds. **C:** Confuses water vapour with smoke. **D:** Thinks clouds contain newly created water. |
    | 3 | **C** | **A:** Confuses infiltration with precipitation. **B:** Confuses evaporation with precipitation. **D:** Confuses condensation with precipitation. |
    | 4 | **A** | **B:** Thinks water must freeze to travel. **C:** Overlooks water moving through soil and underground. **D:** Thinks soaking into soil destroys water. |
    | 5 | **A** | **B:** Confuses water with energy from sunlight. **C:** Thinks plants prevent evaporation. **D:** Thinks plants create water rather than take it up and release some of it. |

    1 message on Pro · $0.0033 to run · 5.3 s · 594 tokens out

  • Gemini 3.8 Flash

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    Here are 5 multiple-choice questions on the water cycle for Year 6 students, complete with answer keys and diagnostic misconceptions for each incorrect option.
    
    ---
    
    ### **Question 1**
    **A puddle on the school playground disappears on a sunny day. What has happened to the water?**
    - A) It soaked through the solid tarmac and into the centre of the Earth.
    - B) It turned into an invisible gas called water vapour and went into the air.
    - C) It boiled and vanished completely from existence.
    - D) It broke down into tiny droplets that floated away as white steam.
    
    **Correct Answer:** **B**
    * **Misconception A:** Believes that all surface water only leaves by absorption/soaking in, ignoring evaporation into the air.
    * **Misconception C:** Confuses everyday evaporation with boiling (100°C), or believes evaporated water ceases to exist (failure of conservation of matter).
    * **Misconception D:** Thinks water vapour is visible "steam" or mist, rather than an invisible gas.
    
    ---
    
    ### **Question 2**
    **What are clouds in the sky actually made of?**
    - A) Water vapour (a gas).
    - B) Spongy cotton-like gas that absorbs water.
    - C) Billions of tiny liquid water droplets or ice crystals.
    - D) Smoke and air pollution that has trapped heat.
    
    **Correct Answer:** **C**
    * **Misconception A:** Confuses the invisible gas phase (water vapour) with the condensed phase; doesn't realise cloud formation requires condensation back into a liquid/solid.
    * **Misconception B:** Thinks clouds are solid, spongy objects that "hold" water like a container.
    * **Misconception D:** Believes clouds are made of smoke or solid particles rather than condensed water.
    
    ---
    
    ### **Question 3**
    **You take a cold can of drink out of the fridge. After a few minutes, drops of water appear on the outside of the can. Where did this water come from?**
    - A) Water leaked through tiny pores in the metal can.
    - B) Coldness pushed through the can and turned into liquid water.
    - C) Water vapour in the surrounding air cooled down and condensed onto the cold can.
    - D) The ice inside the can melted and overflowed down the sides.
    
    **Correct Answer:** **C**
    * **Misconception A:** Believes containers "sweat" by leaking liquid from inside to outside.
    * **Misconception B:** Views "cold" as a physical substance that can transform into matter.
    * **Misconception D:** Assumes external moisture must originate from within the container rather than from the surrounding atmosphere.
    
    ---
    
    ### **Question 4**
    **Which of the following is an example of *precipitation* in the water cycle?**
    - A) Hail falling during a thunderstorm.
    - B) Morning dew forming on blades of grass.
    - C) Fog hanging low over a field.
    - D) Plants releasing water through their leaves.
    
    **Correct Answer:** **A**
    * **Misconception B:** Confuses *condensation* at ground level (dew) with *precipitation* (water falling from clouds).
    * **Misconception C:** Confuses a ground-level cloud (fog) with precipitation.
    * **Misconception D:** Confuses *transpiration* with precipitation.
    
    ---
    
    ### **Question 5**
    **Why is the total amount of water on Earth roughly the same today as it was during the time of the dinosaurs?**
    - A) New water is constantly created by ocean plants to replace what is lost.
    - B) Water moves continuously through a closed cycle of changing states without being destroyed.
    - C) The polar ice caps lock away water permanently so it can never escape.
    - D) Rain continuously adds brand new water from outer space to our atmosphere.
    
    **Correct Answer:** **B**
    * **Misconception A:** Believes that natural processes "create" entirely new water rather than recycling existing water.
    * **Misconception C:** Thinks ice permanently removes water from the cycle, rather than acting as temporary storage.
    * **Misconception D:** Believes rain is "new" water entering Earth's system rather than recycled surface water.

    1 message on Pro · $0.0019 to run · 5.1 s · 923 tokens out

  • Claude Haiku 4.5

    Failed

    Graded 3.7 of 5 on average (lowest 2).

    # Water Cycle Quiz – Year 6
    
    ## Question 1
    Which process describes water turning from a liquid into a gas?
    - A) Evaporation ✓
    - B) Condensation (misconception: confuses evaporation with condensation)
    - C) Freezing (misconception: thinks phase change to gas requires a solid state)
    - D) Precipitation (misconception: confuses evaporation with falling water)
    
    ---
    
    ## Question 2
    Where does most of the water that evaporates come from?
    - A) Rivers and streams (misconception: underestimates ocean's role)
    - B) Lakes (misconception: thinks lakes are the primary source)
    - C) The oceans ✓
    - D) Clouds (misconception: thinks water originates in the atmosphere)
    
    ---
    
    ## Question 3
    What happens to water vapour when it rises high into the atmosphere and cools down?
    - A) It evaporates more (misconception: thinks cooling increases evaporation)
    - B) It condenses into liquid water droplets ✓
    - C) It freezes into ice crystals only (misconception: thinks condensation only produces ice)
    - D) It stays as a gas forever (misconception: thinks water vapour never changes)
    
    ---
    
    ## Question 4
    Which of these is an example of precipitation?
    - A) Evaporation (misconception: confuses processes within the water cycle)
    - B) A puddle forming in the sun (misconception: thinks all water movement is precipitation)
    - C) Snow falling from clouds ✓
    - D) Water seeping into the ground (misconception: confuses infiltration with precipitation)
    
    ---
    
    ## Question 5
    What is the name of the process where water soaks into the ground?
    - A) Evaporation (misconception: thinks this only happens at the surface)
    - B) Condensation (misconception: confuses atmospheric and ground processes)
    - C) Infiltration ✓
    - D) Sublimation (misconception: thinks this is how water enters soil)
    
    ---
    
    ## Answer Key
    1. **A** | 2. **C** | 3. **B** | 4. **C** | 5. **C**

    1 message on Pro · $0.0030 to run · 5.9 s · 512 tokens out

5. Kind, specific feedback on student work

Everyday · 4 of 4 passed

Two strengths and one improvement, with an example, is feedback a student can use; the word limit keeps it readable.

The prompt: replace the parts in [brackets]

Write feedback to the student on this paragraph: two things done well and one thing to improve, with an example of how. Under 100 words, written to the student. [paste the student's work]

Open in llmwise
How we filled it in and checked the replies
Write feedback to the student on this paragraph: two things done well and one thing to improve, with an example of how. Under 100 words, written to the student.

I think school uniforms are bad because they are uncomfortable and everyone looks the same. Also they cost a lot. My friend said she hates hers. So schools should not have uniforms.
  • Specific: The strengths and the improvement refer to this paragraph.
  • Actionable: The improvement comes with a concrete example.
  • To the student: Kind, encouraging and written to the student.
  • Automatic rules: at most 100 words.
  • GPT-6 Luna

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    You clearly state your opinion, and you give several reasons to support it, including discomfort, cost, and lack of individuality. To improve, add an example or explanation to make one reason more convincing. For instance: “Uniforms can be expensive because families may need to buy special clothes in addition to everyday outfits.”

    1 message on Pro · under $0.0001 to run · 1.8 s · 67 tokens out

  • GPT-6 Sol

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    You clearly state your opinion, and you give several reasons for it, including comfort and cost. You also include your friend’s experience, which makes the issue feel personal. To make your argument stronger, add a specific example that explains one reason. For instance: “My uniform’s stiff collar makes it hard to stay comfortable during a long school day.”

    1 message on Pro · $0.0008 to run · 1.4 s · 74 tokens out

  • Gemini 3.8 Flash

    Passed

    Graded 5.0 of 5 on average (lowest 5).

    Great job clearly stating your opinion right away and including multiple reasons—like cost and comfort—to support your stance. 
    
    To improve, strengthen your argument by using stronger evidence instead of just personal opinions or what a friend said. 
    
    **Example:** Instead of *"My friend said she hates hers,"* try writing, *"Uniforms prevent students from expressing their individuality, and families often spend hundreds of dollars each year replacing them."* This makes your point much more persuasive!

    1 message on Pro · $0.0003 to run · 1.1 s · 96 tokens out

  • Claude Haiku 4.5

    Passed

    Graded 4.3 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    **Great work on:**
    1. **Clear position** – You state your argument upfront, making it easy to follow.
    2. **Multiple reasons** – You support your view with practical points (comfort, cost, appearance).
    
    **To improve:**
    Instead of relying on personal anecdotes ("my friend said"), strengthen your argument with evidence. For example: "Studies show students report higher stress in restrictive uniforms" or "The average uniform costs $200+ annually, straining families." This makes your argument more persuasive and credible.

    1 message on Pro · $0.0010 to run · 2.0 s · 120 tokens out

6. A trip letter to parents

Everyday · 2 of 4 passed

Pasting every detail means nothing parents need is left out or made up.

The prompt: replace the parts in [brackets]

Write an email to parents about a school trip using these details. Under 150 words. [the details]

Open in llmwise
How we filled it in and checked the replies
Write an email to parents about a school trip using these details. Under 150 words.

Year 4 trip to the Science Museum, Thursday 20 November
Leave 9:00, back by 15:30
Cost £12, pay online by Friday 7 November
Packed lunch needed, no nuts
Consent form attached
  • Every detail: Date, times, cost and deadline, packed lunch with no nuts, the consent form.
  • Clear: Easy to scan, with the action parents must take obvious.
  • Nothing added: No invented details.
  • Automatic rules: at most 150 words; includes “20 November”; includes “12”; includes “7 November”; includes “nut”.
  • GPT-6 Luna

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    **Subject: Year 4 Trip to the Science Museum**
    
    Dear Parents and Carers,
    
    Year 4 will visit the Science Museum on Thursday 20 November. We will leave school at 9:00 and return by 15:30.
    
    The cost is £12 per child. Please pay online by Friday 7 November and return the attached consent form.
    
    Children should bring a packed lunch. Please ensure it contains no nuts.
    
    Kind regards,  
    [School/Teacher Name]

    1 message on Pro · under $0.0001 to run · 1.4 s · 100 tokens out

  • GPT-6 Sol

    Passed

    Graded 4.3 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    **Subject: Year 4 Trip to the Science Museum – Thursday 20 November**
    
    Dear Parents and Carers,
    
    Year 4 will visit the Science Museum on Thursday 20 November. We will leave school at 9:00 am and return by 3:30 pm.
    
    The trip costs £12. Please pay online by Friday 7 November and complete the attached consent form.
    
    Please provide your child with a packed lunch. To keep everyone safe, please do not include any nuts.
    
    Kind regards,  
    Year 4 Team

    1 message on Pro · $0.0010 to run · 1.5 s · 110 tokens out

  • Gemini 3.8 Flash

    Failed

    Graded 3.7 of 5 on average (lowest 2).

    Subject: Year 4 Trip to the Science Museum – Thursday 20 November
    
    Dear Parents and Carers,
    
    We are excited to announce that Year 4 will be visiting the Science Museum on Thursday 20 November. 
    
    We will depart school promptly at 9:00 AM and return by 3:30 PM. 
    
    The cost of the trip is £12 per child. Please make your payment via our online school portal by Friday 7 November. 
    
    Children will need to bring a packed lunch and a water bottle in a backpack. Please note that we are a strictly nut-free school, so ensure lunches contain no nut products. 
    
    Please complete and return the attached consent form by Friday 7 November to secure your child's place.
    
    Thank you for your continued support.
    
    Warm regards,
    
    The Year 4 Team

    1 message on Pro · $0.0005 to run · 1.3 s · 178 tokens out

  • Claude Haiku 4.5

    Failed

    Graded 3.7 of 5 on average (lowest 2).

    **Subject: Year 4 Science Museum Trip – Thursday 20 November**
    
    Dear Parents and Guardians,
    
    We're excited to announce that Year 4 will be visiting the Science Museum on **Thursday 20 November**. 
    
    **Trip Details:**
    - **Departure:** 9:00 AM
    - **Return:** 3:30 PM
    - **Cost:** £12 (pay online by Friday 7 November)
    - **What to bring:** Packed lunch (please ensure it is nut-free)
    
    A consent form is attached—please complete and return it by Friday 7 November.
    
    This is a wonderful opportunity for the children to explore interactive exhibits and enhance their learning through hands-on experience.
    
    If you have any questions, please don't hesitate to contact us.
    
    Best regards,
    [School Name]

    1 message on Pro · $0.0014 to run · 2.6 s · 188 tokens out

7. One concept at three ages

Everyday · 4 of 4 passed

The same idea at three levels is a ready-made plan for mixed classes, and a check on accuracy at each.

The prompt: replace the parts in [brackets]

Explain [your concept] three ways: for a 7-year-old, a 12-year-old and a 16-year-old, a short paragraph each.

Open in llmwise
How we filled it in and checked the replies
Explain why the seasons change three ways: for a 7-year-old, a 12-year-old and a 16-year-old, a short paragraph each.
  • Accurate: Every version gets the tilt of the Earth right, not the distance from the Sun.
  • Three levels: The language and depth rise with age.
  • Clear: Each paragraph stands on its own.
  • GPT-6 Luna

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    **For a 7-year-old:** Earth goes around the Sun, and it’s tilted a little like a spinning top. When your part of Earth tilts toward the Sun, the days are warmer and longer—that’s summer. When it tilts away, days are cooler and shorter—that’s winter.
    
    **For a 12-year-old:** Earth’s axis—the imaginary line it spins around—is tilted about 23.5 degrees. As Earth orbits the Sun, each hemisphere takes turns tilting toward or away from the Sun. Tilting toward brings more direct sunlight and longer days, making summer; tilting away brings less direct sunlight and shorter days, making winter.
    
    **For a 16-year-old:** Seasons happen because Earth’s axis is tilted about 23.5 degrees relative to its orbit around the Sun, not because Earth gets much closer to or farther from the Sun. During the year, the tilt changes the angle at which sunlight reaches each hemisphere and the length of daylight. More direct sunlight and longer days mean more energy reaches the ground, producing summer; less direct sunlight and shorter days produce winter.

    1 message on Pro · $0.0001 to run · 3.0 s · 228 tokens out

  • GPT-6 Sol

    Passed

    Graded 5.0 of 5 on average (lowest 5).

    **For a 7-year-old:** Earth travels around the Sun, and it spins while leaning a little to one side. When your part of Earth leans toward the Sun, the days are longer and warmer: summer! When it leans away, the days are shorter and colder: winter.
    
    **For a 12-year-old:** Seasons happen because Earth’s axis—the imaginary line it spins around—is tilted as Earth orbits the Sun. For part of the year, your hemisphere tilts toward the Sun, getting longer days and more direct sunlight. That makes it warmer. About six months later, it tilts away, getting shorter days and less direct sunlight, so it’s colder.
    
    **For a 16-year-old:** Earth’s axis is tilted about 23.5° relative to its orbit around the Sun. As Earth orbits, that tilt changes the angle at which sunlight reaches each hemisphere and the number of daylight hours. More direct sunlight and longer days deliver more energy per square metre, producing summer; less direct sunlight and shorter days produce winter. The hemispheres have opposite seasons, and Earth’s changing distance from the Sun is not the main cause.

    1 message on Pro · $0.0016 to run · 3.7 s · 239 tokens out

  • Gemini 3.8 Flash

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    **For a 7-year-old:**
    Imagine the Earth is like a spinning top that leans slightly to one side as it circles the sun. When the part where we live leans toward the warm sun, we get longer, sunnier days, which is summer. When our part leans away, the sun’s rays are weaker, making the days shorter and colder, which is winter. 
    
    **For a 12-year-old:**
    The seasons change because the Earth is tilted on its axis at about 23.5 degrees as it orbits the sun. This tilt means different hemispheres receive different amounts of direct sunlight throughout the year. When the Northern Hemisphere is tilted toward the sun, it gets direct light and longer days (summer), while the Southern Hemisphere is tilted away, getting indirect light and shorter days (winter).
    
    **For a 16-year-old:**
    Earth's seasons are caused by its constant axial tilt of 23.5° relative to its orbital plane (the ecliptic) during its annual revolution around the sun. This tilt alters the angle of incidence of incoming solar radiation (insolation). Direct rays concentrate thermal energy over a smaller surface area and travel through less atmosphere during the summer solstice, while shallow-angle rays disperse energy over a wider area during the winter solstice, driving the global climatic cycle.

    1 message on Pro · $0.0007 to run · 2.2 s · 277 tokens out

  • Claude Haiku 4.5

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    # Why Seasons Change
    
    **For a 7-year-old:**
    The Earth is like a spinning top that's tilted. As it goes around the sun, different parts of Earth lean toward or away from the sun. When your part leans toward the sun, it gets hot and sunny — that's summer! When it leans away, it gets cold and dark — that's winter. Spring and fall happen when your part is in between.
    
    **For a 12-year-old:**
    Seasons happen because Earth's axis is tilted at about 23.5 degrees. As Earth orbits the sun, this tilt means different hemispheres receive sunlight at different angles and for different lengths of time. When your hemisphere tilts toward the sun, you get more direct sunlight and longer days (summer). When it tilts away, sunlight spreads out more and days are shorter (winter). The angle of sunlight actually matters — it's hotter when sun rays come straight down than when they're at an angle.
    
    **For a 16-year-old:**
    Earth's axial tilt of 23.5° creates seasons by varying solar irradiance and photoperiod. When a hemisphere is tilted toward the sun, it receives more direct insolation (shorter atmospheric path, higher angle of incidence), more daylight hours, and concentrated energy density. Conversely, tilted-away hemispheres receive diffuse insolation at lower angles with greater atmospheric scattering, shorter days, and lower energy flux. This differential heating drives seasonal climate patterns. The tilt is constant, but its orientation relative to Earth's position in its elliptical orbit creates the cyclical seasonal variation.

    1 message on Pro · $0.0022 to run · 4.4 s · 367 tokens out

8. Discussion questions beyond recall

Everyday · 4 of 4 passed

Ruling out one-fact answers gets questions that start a discussion.

The prompt: replace the parts in [brackets]

Write 6 discussion questions about [the text] for [your class], as a numbered list, none of which can be answered with a single fact from the text.

Open in llmwise
How we filled it in and checked the replies
Write 6 discussion questions about the fable of the tortoise and the hare for Year 3, as a numbered list, none of which can be answered with a single fact from the text.
  • Beyond recall: No question can be answered with a single fact.
  • Level: Suits Year 3.
  • Varied: Mix of why, what if and opinion questions.
  • Automatic rules: exactly 6 bullet points.
  • GPT-6 Luna

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    1. Why do you think the hare was so sure he would win, and what might have changed his mind?
    2. How do the tortoise’s choices help him in the race?
    3. Was the hare’s nap a sensible choice? Explain why or why not.
    4. How might the race have gone differently if the hare had treated the tortoise with more respect?
    5. What do you think the tortoise felt when he saw the hare sleeping, and what might he have done next?
    6. What lesson do you think the story teaches about trying hard, and how could you use that lesson in your own life?

    1 message on Pro · $0.0001 to run · 2.2 s · 131 tokens out

  • GPT-6 Sol

    Passed

    Graded 4.3 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    1. Why do you think the hare was so sure he would win? What would you say to him before the race?
    2. How did the tortoise keep going when the hare was far ahead?
    3. Why did the hare decide to rest? What else could he have chosen to do?
    4. How might each animal have felt when the tortoise crossed the finish line?
    5. What do you think the hare learned from the race? Do you think he would race differently next time?
    6. When might being steady and not giving up help you in your own life?

    1 message on Pro · $0.0010 to run · 1.8 s · 121 tokens out

  • Gemini 3.8 Flash

    Passed

    Graded 5.0 of 5 on average (lowest 5).

    1. Why do you think the Hare was so confident that he decided to take a nap during the race?
    2. How do you think the Tortoise felt at the start of the race compared to how he felt at the very end?
    3. If the Tortoise had seen the Hare sleeping, do you think it would have been fair to wake him up? Why or why not?
    4. What advice would you give to the Hare so he can be a better sport in the future?
    5. Can you think of a time when taking your time helped you do something better than rushing?
    6. If they ran the race again tomorrow, what do you think would happen and why?

    1 message on Pro · $0.0004 to run · 1.5 s · 143 tokens out

  • Claude Haiku 4.5

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    # Discussion Questions: The Tortoise and the Hare
    
    1. **Why do you think the hare was so confident about winning the race?** What made him believe he didn't need to try hard?
    
    2. **How might the story have been different if the hare had stayed awake during his nap?** What does this tell us about being overconfident?
    
    3. **Was it fair for the tortoise to challenge the hare to a race when he knew he was slower?** What gave him the courage to do this?
    
    4. **What do you think the tortoise was thinking about while he was running slowly?** How might his thoughts have helped him keep going?
    
    5. **Have you ever seen someone like the hare or the tortoise in real life?** What happened to them, and what did you learn from watching them?
    
    6. **If the hare and tortoise raced again, what do you think would happen differently?** What lesson do you think the hare would have learned?

    1 message on Pro · $0.0015 to run · 3.1 s · 223 tokens out

9. Mark an answer against a mark scheme

Hard · 3 of 4 passed

Marking point by point, then totalling, is how a mark scheme works; the trap is giving the mark for one product of two.

The prompt: replace the parts in [brackets]

Mark this student's answer against the mark scheme. Give one line per mark point saying whether it's met, then end with a line "Final answer: " and the total marks. Mark scheme: [the mark scheme] Student answer: [the student's answer]

Open in llmwise
How we filled it in and checked the replies
Mark this student's answer against the mark scheme. Give one line per mark point saying whether it's met, then end with a line "Final answer: " and the total marks.

Mark scheme: 3 marks. 1 mark: names the process as photosynthesis. 1 mark: says it happens in chloroplasts (or uses chlorophyll). 1 mark: names both products, glucose and oxygen.

Student answer: In photosynthesis, plants use light to turn carbon dioxide and water into glucose, which they use for energy.
  • Checked automatically: the reply's last “Final answer:” line must give 1.
  • GPT-6 Luna

    Passed

    Final answer 1/3 marks: right.

    - Names photosynthesis: **Met**
    - Says it happens in chloroplasts or uses chlorophyll: **Not met**
    - Names both glucose and oxygen: **Not met** (glucose is named, but oxygen is not)
    
    Final answer: 1/3 marks

    1 message on Pro · under $0.0001 to run · 1.1 s · 59 tokens out

  • GPT-6 Sol

    Passed

    Final answer 1/3 marks: right.

    - Photosynthesis named: Met (1 mark).
    - Chloroplasts or chlorophyll mentioned: Not met (0 marks).
    - Both glucose and oxygen named: Not met; only glucose is named (0 marks).
    Final answer: 1/3 marks

    1 message on Pro · $0.0007 to run · 1.2 s · 55 tokens out

  • Gemini 3.8 Flash

    Passed

    Final answer 1/3 marks: right.

    - Mark point 1 (names the process as photosynthesis): Met (student mentions "photosynthesis").
    - Mark point 2 (says it happens in chloroplasts / uses chlorophyll): Not met (no mention of chloroplasts or chlorophyll).
    - Mark point 3 (names both products, glucose and oxygen): Not met (mentions glucose, but fails to mention oxygen).
    
    Final answer: 1/3 marks

    1 message on Pro · $0.0003 to run · 1.1 s · 85 tokens out

  • Claude Haiku 4.5

    Failed

    Final answer 2 marks; expected 1.

    **Mark breakdown:**
    
    1. Names the process as photosynthesis — **Met** ✓
    2. Says it happens in chloroplasts (or uses chlorophyll) — **Not met** ✗
    3. Names both products, glucose and oxygen — **Partially met** ✓ (names glucose but not oxygen)
    
    Final answer: 2 marks

    1 message on Pro · $0.0009 to run · 1.4 s · 85 tokens out

10. A fill-in-the-blanks worksheet

Everyday · 4 of 4 passed

A word bank and answer key make the worksheet ready to print and self-mark.

The prompt: replace the parts in [brackets]

Make a fill-in-the-blanks worksheet from this paragraph: remove 8 key words, number the blanks, and give a word bank and an answer key. [paste the paragraph]

Open in llmwise
How we filled it in and checked the replies
Make a fill-in-the-blanks worksheet from this paragraph: remove 8 key words, number the blanks, and give a word bank and an answer key.

Volcanoes form where magma from inside the Earth rises to the surface. Most are found along the edges of tectonic plates. When pressure builds up, the volcano erupts, releasing lava, ash and gases. Lava that cools quickly forms rocks such as basalt. Some volcanoes are dormant, which means they have not erupted for a long time but could erupt again.
  • Eight blanks: Exactly 8 numbered blanks.
  • Key words: The removed words are the key terms, like magma, tectonic, lava, basalt and dormant.
  • Bank and key: Includes a word bank and a correct answer key.
  • GPT-6 Luna

    Passed

    Graded 4.3 of 5 on average (lowest 3).

    ## Volcanoes: Fill in the Blanks
    
    **Word bank:** basalt · dormant · ash · pressure · edges · magma · erupts · surface
    
    Volcanoes form where (1) __________ from inside the Earth rises to the (2) __________. Most are found along the (3) __________ of tectonic plates. When (4) __________ builds up, the volcano (5) __________, releasing lava, (6) __________ and gases. Lava that cools quickly forms rocks such as (7) __________. Some volcanoes are (8) __________, which means they have not erupted for a long time but could erupt again.
    
    ### Answer Key
    1. magma  
    2. surface  
    3. edges  
    4. pressure  
    5. erupts  
    6. ash  
    7. basalt  
    8. dormant

    1 message on Pro · $0.0001 to run · 2.5 s · 215 tokens out

  • GPT-6 Sol

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    ## Volcanoes: Fill in the Blanks
    
    Fill each numbered blank using a word from the bank.
    
    Volcanoes form where **(1) ________** from inside the Earth rises to the **(2) ________**. Most are found along the edges of **(3) ________** plates. When **(4) ________** builds up, the volcano erupts, releasing lava, **(5) ________** and gases. Lava that cools quickly forms rocks such as **(6) ________**. Some volcanoes are **(7) ________**, which means they have not erupted for a long time but could **(8) ________** again.
    
    **Word bank:** ash · basalt · dormant · erupt · magma · pressure · surface · tectonic
    
    **Answer key:** 1. magma  2. surface  3. tectonic  4. pressure  5. ash  6. basalt  7. dormant  8. erupt

    1 message on Pro · $0.0023 to run · 3.6 s · 367 tokens out

  • Gemini 3.8 Flash

    Passed

    Graded 4.7 of 5 on average (lowest 4).

    ### Volcanoes Worksheet
    
    **Instructions:** Fill in the numbered blanks using the correct words from the word bank.
    
    ---
    
    Volcanoes form where **(1)** ________ from inside the Earth rises to the **(2)** ________. Most are found along the edges of tectonic **(3)** ________. When **(4)** ________ builds up, the volcano erupts, releasing **(5)** ________, ash and gases. Lava that cools quickly forms rocks such as **(6)** ________. Some volcanoes are **(7)** ________, which means they have not **(8)** ________ for a long time but could erupt again.
    
    ---
    
    ### Word Bank
    * basalt
    * dormant
    * erupted
    * lava
    * magma
    * plates
    * pressure
    * surface
    
    ---
    
    ### Answer Key
    1. magma
    2. surface
    3. plates
    4. pressure
    5. lava
    6. basalt
    7. dormant
    8. erupted

    1 message on Pro · $0.0005 to run · 1.6 s · 197 tokens out

  • Claude Haiku 4.5

    Passed

    Graded 4.0 of 5 on average (lowest 3).

    # Volcano Fill-in-the-Blanks Worksheet
    
    Volcanoes form where ___1___ from inside the Earth rises to the surface. Most are found along the edges of ___2___ plates. When pressure builds up, the volcano ___3___, releasing ___4___, ash and gases. Lava that cools quickly forms rocks such as ___5___. Some volcanoes are ___6___, which means they have not ___7___ for a long time but could ___8___ again.
    
    ---
    
    ## Word Bank
    basalt | dormant | erupts | erupt | lava | magma | tectonic | erupted
    
    ---
    
    ## Answer Key
    1. magma
    2. tectonic
    3. erupts
    4. lava
    5. basalt
    6. dormant
    7. erupted
    8. erupt

    1 message on Pro · $0.0015 to run · 2.0 s · 201 tokens out

Getting more from these prompts

  • Give the year group and the lesson length; both change the plan.

  • Paste the mark scheme and ask for a line per mark point before the total.

  • Ask for the misconception behind each wrong answer in a quiz.

  • Remove student names and details before pasting any work.

How we ran and checked them

Each prompt was sent the way llmwise sends a message: the app's own system prompt, each model's own settings, and Pro's reply size limit (8,000 tokens), through OpenRouter. Every reply is shown as it came.

Rubric (graded). The grader model scores the reply from 1 to 5 on each published criterion. It passes with an average of 4 or more and no criterion under 3, and only if it also meets the prompt's automatic rules (length, words it must or mustn't use).

Final answer. Automatic. The reply's last “Final answer:” line must hold the right value.

The grader is Claude Opus 5.5 at low reasoning effort; its own replies are graded by GPT-6 Astra, so no model grades itself. Its prompt is on our test runs page.

More tested prompts

Questions

Which AI is best for teachers?

In our runs, GPT-6 Luna and GPT-6 Sol each passed 10 of 10, the most. The lesson plan is checked on whether its minutes add up and the marking prompt on its total; the rest are graded against a published rubric.

Can AI mark student work?

Use AI marking as a second opinion, not the final mark: in our runs, a model given a clear mark scheme still sometimes gave a mark the scheme didn't allow.

Is it safe to paste student work?

Don't paste anything that identifies a student. The prompts here use made-up work, and you can do the same with names removed.

Claude, GPT, Gemini, DeepSeek, Grok, Kimi, and GLM, in one chat.

See what a message costs before you send it. Free is 5 messages to try; sign in with an email link, no password or card.